GHG Protocol Scope 2 Changes: A Guide to Renewable Electricity Claims 

Proposed GHG Protocol Scope 2 updates would add hourly matching and deliverability tests. See what that means for RECs, PPAs and your renewable claims.

|

hand,holding,to,select,between,green,factory,and,pollution,manufacturing
Senior Sustainability Consultant
Topics covered in this article
Other blog posts you might like
Climate Week 2026 Reflections
What Happens When You Ask Real Estate Leaders If Sustainability Data Actually Changes Decisions
See Tango in action
Discover how we help organizations manage their real estate lifecycle.

Imagine walking into an office building and seeing a sign that says, “100% Powered by Renewable Energy.” It sounds promising. But what does it mean? Does the building receive electricity directly from nearby wind turbines or solar panels? Did the company help fund a new renewable energy project? Or did it purchase certificates that support a renewable electricity claim? 

These distinctions matter as the Greenhouse Gas Protocol (GHG Protocol) considers updates to its Scope 2 accounting guidance. The proposed changes would place greater emphasis on when and where renewable electricity is generated, not just how much a company purchases. 

Scope 2: What is changing? 

Scope 2 covers emissions associated with purchased electricity, steam, heat and cooling. Companies commonly report these emissions using two methods: 

Location-based method Market-based method 
Uses the average emissions intensity of the grid where a facility consumes electricity, such as eGRID rates in the U.S. Considers renewable energy purchases when accounting for emissions. Electricity not covered by renewable energy is typically multiplied by a Green-e residual rate. 

The proposed market-based updates would put stricter rules around which renewable energy purchases can be considered under scope 2 market-based emissions calculations. Two questions are central: 

  • When was the renewable electricity generated? Does it match the hours when the company actually uses electricity? 
  • Where was it generated? Is the renewable energy coming from a grid region that can reasonably serve the company’s electricity demand? 

As of November 2026, these changes remain under development; they are not finalized reporting requirements. To understand their implications, let’s explore two common tool’s for renewable electricity claims: renewable energy certificates (RECs) and power purchase agreements (PPA’s). 

image

RECs 

What is a renewable energy certificate (REC)? 

Unless you generate your own power, such as with solar panels connected directly to your building, you can’t choose the specific electricity you use. Everything on the grid is mixed together, coming from renewable projects, fossil fuel plants, and other sources. A renewable energy credit lets you claim the renewable part of that mix. 

Renewable energy certificates, also called RECs, are certificates that document, authenticate and track that energy flowing into the power grid comes from a clean, renewable power source.  One REC represents the renewable attributes of 1 megawatt-hour (MWh) of renewable electricity generation. The electricity and its renewable attributes can be sold together (bundled) or separately (unbundled). 

RECs can come from wind, solar and other eligible renewable generation across different projects and regions. State and regional entities track and verify RECs. The Center for Resource Solutions operates the Green-e® Energy program, one system used to verify RECs.  

REC prices vary with supply and demand, certificate type, location, buyer requirements and eligibility for compliance markets. Any quoted price range should be treated as specific to its market and time period, not as a universal price. 

Here’s how a REC works in practice: 

  1. A renewable energy project generates 1 MWh of electricity that feeds into the grid. That grid doesn’t have to be the one that serves the buyer.  
  2. A REC is issued for the renewable attributes of that generation. 
  3. A buyer purchases the REC with the electricity (bundled) or separately (unbundled). Under current rules, a company in Boston can generally claim a REC from a wind farm in North Dakota. 
  4. The REC is retired in the relevant tracking system on the buyer’s behalf, preventing its reuse for another claim. 
  5. The buyer uses eligible, retired RECs in market-based Scope 2 accounting, subject to applicable rules. 

          What’s the difference between bundled vs unbundled RECS? 

          Think of buying milk. If you buy regular milk and separately purchase a certificate for an equivalent amount of organic milk, the certificate supports the organic farmer but doesn’t change the milk in your carton. That’s an unbundled purchase. If you buy organic milk that comes with its certificate, you get the product and its attributes together. That’s bundled. 

          Electricity works the same way. With unbundled RECs, you buy the certificates separately from your electricity. They can support a renewable electricity claim, but they aren’t tied to the power your building uses. With bundled RECs, the certificates come together with the electricity from a specific project, so the power and its renewable attributes are purchased as one package. 

          Additionality: Does buying RECs help create new renewable projects? 

          Additionality is the question of whether your purchase helped a new clean energy project get built, rather than just supporting one that already exists. For RECs, the answer depends on the type. 

          Unbundled RECs are typically bought from projects that are already operating. The revenue is one source of income alongside electricity sales and policy support, so it helps the project without necessarily causing it to expand. Like buying a concert ticket, the purchase supports the show without necessarily paying for a bigger venue. Research generally finds a weak link between unbundled RECs and new construction, though researchers disagree on how large the effect is. 

          Bundled RECs can work differently. Because they are purchased together with a project’s electricity, often under a long-term contract, they can give a developer the committed revenue needed to finance a new project. The case is strongest when the contract is signed before construction begins and the project relies on it to get financed. Even then, additionality isn’t guaranteed. It depends on the timing and terms of the deal. 

          Why do REC-based claims attract greenwashing criticism? 

          A company may buy enough RECs to match its annual electricity use and report lower market-based Scope 2 emissions while still receiving power from a grid that includes fossil fuels. Critics argue that the purchase does not change the electricity physically delivered to the building or necessarily reduce grid emissions in the hour it is used. The distinction is between an accounting claim and its physical impact. 

          PPAs 

          What is a power purchase agreement (PPA)? 

          A power purchase agreement (PPA) is a contract to buy electricity from a specific generator, often a renewable energy project, under agreed commercial terms. 

          Think of a business agreeing to buy a farmer’s future harvest. Having a committed buyer can help the farmer secure financing and invest in growing the crop. Similarly, a long-term PPA can give a renewable energy developer greater revenue certainty and help support a new project. The effect depends on the financing and contract terms. 

          What’s the difference between physical vs virtual PPA’s? 

          A PPA can be physical or virtual.  

          In a physical PPA, the buyer receives the electricity from the project, along with its RECs. The buyer pays the project’s price for that power. 

          In a virtual PPA, no electricity is delivered. The project sells its power on the open market, and the buyer agrees to a fixed price for that output over many years. If the market price is lower, the buyer pays the difference, and if it is higher, the buyer receives the difference. The buyer keeps buying power from its usual supplier and typically receives the project’s RECs. Because the settlement depends on market prices, the buyer can gain or lose money on the contract. 

          Additionality: Does a PPA help create new renewable projects? 

          It can, but it depends on timing and terms. A long-term PPA gives a developer a committed buyer and predictable revenue, which can help secure the financing needed to build a project. That is a stronger link to new construction than an unbundled REC, which is typically a smaller add-on revenue stream for a project that already exists. Corporate contracts like these have accounted for a large share of recent U.S. renewable development. 

          Timing matters most. Like the farmer’s harvest, a commitment made before planting can change what gets grown, while one made after the harvest mainly pays for what already exists. A PPA signed before construction, for a project that needed the contract to get financed, is the strongest case. A PPA with a project that is already operating, or one that would have been built anyway, mainly provides revenue without adding new clean energy to the grid. Either way, additionality isn’t automatic, and it depends on the deal. 

          What’s changing: Matching renewable energy to time and location  

          Hourly matching: Does the timing line up? 

          Imagine an office uses 1 MWh at 7 p.m. on a winter evening but buys a REC for solar electricity generated at noon on a summer afternoon. The annual totals may match, but the generation and use occurred in different hours. Hourly matching seeks a closer alignment between renewable electricity generation and the hours when a company uses electricity. 

          Geographic deliverability: Can the region serve the demand? 

          Imagine a company buys RECs from Texas while all its operations are in Boston. The proposed changes would place greater emphasis on whether the renewable electricity was generated in a grid region that can reasonably supply the company’s electricity demand. 

          How are companies reacting to these proposals? 

          The public consultation showed that most companies are resistant to the stricter proposals. Only 12% of respondents supported hourly matching, while 82% expressed low or no support. Deliverability fared only slightly better, with 19% in support and 71% expressing low or no support. 

          Respondents raised specific concerns about each. For hourly matching, the main worry was that it could discourage companies outside the U.S. from participating in voluntary clean energy markets (as reported by ESG Today). For deliverability, 87% of respondents said that tighter market boundaries would limit their ability to invest where renewable projects could cut the most emissions, and 72% said the requirement could push companies away from long-term agreements and toward spot purchases. 

          What does this mean for renewable claims? 

          Under the proposed changes, claims that are closely tied to a specific project, time, and place carry the least risk. Unbundled RECs carry the most risk, since they are the claims most likely to fail an hourly matching or deliverability test if annual matching is no longer accepted. For now, most companies are carrying on as usual and buying RECs the way they historically have. If the hourly matching proposal is adopted, many companies will likely scale back REC purchases, particularly those that currently choose the cheapest Green-e certified mix to meet reporting requirements rather than paying more for local or in-market options, even though those options tend to have greater impact. 

          How can companies prepare? 

          1. Understand your electricity use, hour by hour where possible. Map consumption by facility and grid region, and check whether interval (hourly) data is available. If it isn’t, the proposal allows load profiles to approximate hourly use from monthly or annual data, and the simplest option, a flat average across all hours, needs no specialized data. Knowing your volumes by region also tells you whether a proposed exemption threshold, based on consumption in a grid region and/or company size, could apply to you. 
          2. Inventory your renewable purchases and the RECs they deliver. List every way you buy renewable electricity: RECs, PPAs, on-site generation, and utility or community programs. For each one, record whether it delivers RECs to you, and if so the volume, project location and grid region, generation date, and whether the certificate has an hourly timestamp. Don’t assume a PPA includes the RECs, because the developer may keep or sell them separately. Keep this documentation either way. A legacy clause is being evaluated to protect investments made under existing rules, and a clear record is the best way to show what you bought and when. 
          3. Separate compliance and voluntary purchases. Identify the RECs bought to meet state requirements and those bought voluntarily to support renewable electricity claims. Only the voluntary ones feed your market-based Scope 2 claim, so that’s the portfolio to stress-test. 
          4. Talk to your energy suppliers and REC providers. Ask which registries issue your certificates, whether hourly timestamped certificates are available for your regions, and where the underlying projects are located relative to your facilities. Hourly certificate data is emerging in a growing number of markets but isn’t universal, so availability will vary by region. 
          5. Bring the right teams together and plan for a phased rollout. Involve sustainability, facilities, finance and procurement before making new commitments or changing existing claims. The revised standard is anticipated in late 2027, with implementation phasing in over multiple years, so the near-term goal is to be prepared, not to overhaul your portfolio. 

                  Key Takeaways: What the Scope 2 changes mean for renewable electricity claims 

                  The proposed GHG Protocol Scope 2 updates would place greater emphasis on when and where renewable electricity is generated, not just how much a company purchases. 

                  • Volume alone may no longer be enough. Right now, a company can buy enough RECs to cover its annual electricity use and report lower market-based Scope 2 emissions. The proposals would also ask when and where that renewable electricity was generated. 
                  • Different instruments support different claims. A REC supports an accounting claim. It doesn’t prove that the building used renewable electricity or that new capacity was built. A long-term PPA may show a stronger link to new projects, depending on its terms. Clear claims say which one is which. 
                  • The rules aren’t final, and the scrutiny is real. Many respondents in the public consultation opposed the proposals, so the final requirements may not match the drafts. Still, questions about timing, location and additionality aren’t going away.  
                  • Today’s contracts may be judged by tomorrow’s rules. PPAs and multi-year REC commitments often outlast reporting cycles. Before signing new agreements, check how they would hold up under hourly matching and deliverability requirements. 
                  • Better claims need better data. If the stricter proposals move forward, companies will need interval-level consumption data, generation timestamps and project locations, not just annual totals. 

                  How Tango Energy & Sustainability helps 

                  Whatever form the final Scope 2 rules take, credible renewable electricity claims rest on two things: accurate consumption data and a clear record of what you’ve purchased. Tango Energy & Sustainability brings your utility, energy and emissions data together in one place, so you can see where your claims stand today and prepare for what’s next. Tango Energy & Sustainability helps: 

                  • Build a reliable consumption baseline. Tango imports utility bills directly from providers and standardizes them into one searchable database. It flags duplicate records and billing gaps before they reach your emissions figures. You can upload interval data alongside bill data to get a more detailed view of when facilities use electricity. 
                  • Keep renewable purchases in one place. Track unbundled and bundled RECs across your portfolio and compare actual production against guaranteed production. You’ll know what you hold and whether it’s delivering what you expected. 
                  • Automate emissions calculations. Calculate Scope 1, 2 and 3 emissions using GHG Protocol corporate standard conversion factors. This replaces spreadsheets and manual standardization across utility providers. 
                  • Report to the frameworks you already use. Format data for the GHG Protocol, GRESB, ENERGY STAR Portfolio Manager and SBTi. Track progress toward net zero goals on dashboards your sustainability, facilities and finance teams can share. 
                  • Plan your next move. Forecast consumption, find peak usage periods and measure the returns on energy initiatives. This helps you decide where renewable procurement and efficiency projects will have the most impact. 

                  The final Scope 2 rules are still taking shape, but the direction is clear: renewable electricity claims will need to show more than annual totals. Request a demo to see how Tango Energy & Sustainability can help you build the data foundation to support them. 

                  Sources  

                  Share this blog post
                  More about the author
                  Senior Sustainability Consultant

                  Driven by a passion for climate technology and policy, Annika is a Senior Sustainability Consultant at Tango. She works closely with organizations to measure and report their carbon footprint, guiding them through the fast-changing world of sustainability regulations and voluntary frameworks like GRESB. Her work sits at the crossroads of innovation and compliance, helping companies translate climate ambition into measurable impact.

                  img 5785

                  Climate Week 2026 Reflections

                  image (2)

                  What Happens When You Ask Real Estate Leaders If Sustainability Data Actually Changes Decisions

                  Keep up to date with industry news

                  Every month, we publish in-depth newsletters and articles exploring emerging trends in workplace and retail management—subscribe to stay in the know!